FBI Raid on Indiana Sports Developer Raises New Questions About Government-Funded Athletic Projects

An FBI raid involving Indiana sports developer Andy Card is drawing renewed attention to the use of public money for athletic facilities and large recreational projects. Federal court filings allege funds tied to a publicly financed fieldhouse project were improperly diverted, fueling broader debate over government oversight, public-private partnerships, and taxpayer-funded sports development across Indiana.

I'm working off an article from the IndyStar. Numerous other publications covered this. Andy Card, who has played a big role in several large Indiana sports developments, often with huge government buy-in, had his Westfield home raided by the FBI. Look, I've said this for years. Government should do certain things and that's it. Like, there's basic things. I saw Abdul and some people were like, well, Rob's going at Abdul over the weekend. Well, if you're gonna post on social media, it's no different than us being here on Statehouse Happenings. I don't feel bad disagreeing with you on social media if you're posting something on social media, because Abdul and I disagree on Statehouse Happenings all the time, and Abdul posted this thing about the plan to get rid of property taxes. And look, I'm against J.D. Prescott's plan because it raises taxes, but Abdul never wants to seem to acknowledge that local governments can make cuts. And I will tell you, as a former member of local government who cut property tax rates 18.5% in four years and beat a school referendum, you could cut the money to local governments in half, and they'd be fine if you actually forced them to budget and prioritize properly. And I'm not just talking schools. I'm talking cities. I'm talking towns. I'm talking counties. I'm talking the library, the fire territories, all of these people. Now, the problem is if you cut their money, they would make you feel the pain where it would hurt you the most, because that's what government does all the time. When they don't get what they want, they make people feel pain versus just budgeting better. There are certain things government should be doing. It's roads, it's bridges, it's sidewalks, it's water, it's sewer, it's public safety, the police, the fire, and taking care of the most vulnerable. You know, like the severely disabled. Those are things governments should do. Beyond that, especially at like a local level, not much. But the government now is in all of these other things at a local level. And one of the things that I've been screaming about this for years, that it is a disaster waiting to happen and now it's playing out, is them getting into the sports arena business.

FBI Raid Targets Prominent Indiana Sports Developer With Ties to Major Public Projects

And it goes way beyond just what we're talking about, like the big ones like Lucas Oil Stadium or Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Like, Lucas Oil Stadium has been a financial dumpster fire. Tomorrow there's a new op-ed out in the Capital Chronicle about what a dumpster fire from an economic standpoint the Bears stadium would be, and we'll talk about that tomorrow. But the sports stadium, or even if you go beyond sports stadiums, the swimming pools, the rec centers, the amphitheaters, none of those are things that government should be involved in. They don't, they're not going to do them well. There's nothing about government that says we're set up to run rec centers or swimming pools or amphitheaters or sports stadiums. Nothing. There is zero in the structure of government that says, yeah, you guys are qualified to run those things well. And yet, because government has confiscated so much money, there is so much being paid in taxes, they have branched out instead of doing what was right and saying, here's what we need, here's how we operate, everything else goes back to you. And you're seeing this at the state level, right? Nikki Kelly was with us on Friday. They're going to have a $5 billion surplus next year. What are they going to do? They're going to spend it. They're not going to give it back to you. Never mind they raised taxes by $1 billion last year to fund the government year over year. They're not going to give it back to you. They're going to spend it and not well. And so what government does is it keeps looking on ways it can grow. And then when it grows beyond where it should be, then it becomes the baseline. Hey, this is us now, right? It's like the TV show, This Is Us. And the baseline then becomes whatever new project they've instituted. Who are you to cut from us? Well, we instituted this project. Well, why did you institute the project? Well, we did, so now it's the baseline. And the government has no idea how to operate sports arenas or rec centers or swimming pools or sports stadiums. And so you run numerous, numerous risks when you engage in these. One of the risks you engage in is who do you partner with to create the thing? Because you can't create the thing. And so eventually you end up getting in bed with people like Andy Card, who I'm going to describe to you here.

Federal Court Documents Detail Alleged Misuse of Money From Mishawaka Fieldhouse Project

Now, Andy Card is a known quantity in Indiana when it comes to building sports type complexes. The biggest one that he's most associated with is probably the Pacers Athletic Center in Westfield. By the way, Card was part of a group who tried to take over Grand Park in Westfield a couple of years ago and almost got it. FBI Public Affairs Officer Chris Bavender said via email the agency conducted, quote, court authorized law enforcement activity at Card's home and business on July 16th, but said she could not provide additional details. Now, based on other reporting, it is believed that the raid was tied to a home in Florida and a Mishawaka city financed fieldhouse project. Now, it is believed Card used money that he obtained from a Mishawaka project to pay for the home in Florida. One of the things, and you've seen this like with Lucas Oil Stadium, it is very hard, if not impossible, to track all the money, right? The return on investment, ROI, and it's hard to track the finances, period. I mean, we've been able to bring you information that's been dug out over time of the hundreds of millions of dollars that are still owed on Lucas Oil Stadium, 20 years after it's been built. We know things like we were paying on the RCA Dome more than a decade after it was demolished, but the actual nuts and bolts and finances of these things, almost impossible. You got to have people who really know what they're doing, and it takes a lot of time to pore through these documents. The raid took place on the same day that the U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Indiana submitted a filing for an asset forfeiture for a four bedroom, six bathroom waterfront home belonging to Card and his wife on Marco Island, Florida, for forfeiture. Documents allege that Card fraudulently used money from the city financed Mishawaka Fieldhouse project to help pay for the purchase of a $6.6 million waterfront home. Court records say that the scheme took place over a two year period from October of 2022 through October of 2024. The City of Mishawaka hired Card's company to develop the $38 million indoor athletic facility with hardwood courts and turf fields. Funding for the project involved tax increment financing and an economic development grant.

Athletic Facilities Across Indiana Renew Debate Over Public-Private Partnerships

Now, Card is way, way bigger than just what's being reported here. Other news media outlets have reported that Card and Associates' portfolio also includes the Farmers Bank Fieldhouse in Lebanon, Precision Garage Door Fieldhouse in Noblesville, Community Sports and Wellness Center in Pendleton, in addition to the Pacers facility in Westfield and Mishawaka Fieldhouse in Mishawaka. So all over the state, huge projects. And this is one of the things that I have been screaming about with the government being involved, either through public private partnership or directly involved in these sports facilities. They're not cut out to do them. They're not. Governments can barely run parks, much less fieldhouses. And when I talk about run them, I'm talking about from, to steal another phrase from somewhere else, conception to live birth. And then after the thing has been constructed, they have no business doing it. None whatsoever. As a developer, Card signed an agreement that with the exception of his fee, the public funding would only be used for the city project, according to the Star. But the forfeiture documents say Card didn't honor the agreement. Instead, he made multiple requests for disbursements to cover construction expenses and then transferred those funds into personal accounts. Government cannot oversee these things. Government cannot oversee government as it exists right now. They have zero reason to be in the public stadium business, in the stadium business period, or the rec center business, or the swimming pool business or the amphitheater business. Well, but so and so has it. Great. If the private sector thinks it'll make money, the private sector will do it.

Case Highlights Broader Questions About Government Oversight of Major Development Projects

Government can't even do the basics, right? The roads, the bridges, the sidewalks, the trash, the water, the sewer, the public safety. It struggles with all the basics. How would we think that they would do a rec center or an amphitheater or a sports stadium or a swimming pool? Why would we think they'd do any of those? Well, yeah, they may exist. Yeah, they may look nice. But in terms of what it actually is for the taxpayers, no. And this is the problem. Then when you can't do something right, you get into bed with other parties, third parties, and look, everybody's innocent until proven guilty. No charges have been filed yet. But the bigger story is government should not be in the stadium business. Period.
Back to transcripts