Judge Accuses Marion County Prosecutor’s Office of Unconstitutional Tax Investigation
By Rob Kendall · July 16, 2026
A Marion County judge has issued a sharply worded ruling criticizing the Marion County Prosecutor's Office and the Indiana Department of Revenue over an investigation into several Broad Ripple businesses. The court alleges the investigation proceeded without probable cause, raising significant constitutional questions about prosecutorial authority, taxpayer privacy, government accountability, and the limits of criminal investigations.
This story came out yesterday and it is potentially a massive story. We'll see what truth gets revealed. But if it is proven, it could be, and I don't want to, like, I'm not trying to do hyperbole here, but if Ryan Mears is proven to have done what this judge alleges, he should be disbarred. It's gross beyond belief.
So Ryan Mears is the Marion County prosecutor, and this case actually dates back to last year. In fact, it's been about a year and it made the news, and it was a huge story in which Robert Sabatini, he owns three prominent bars in Broad Ripple, Rock Lobster, Mineshaft Saloon, Average Joe's Sports Pub. He owned those three bars, and he was charged last year with 27 felony counts for allegedly under-reporting sales. So basically, he wasn't paying his taxes. He was underreporting the revenue that was coming in.
And Ryan Mears, the Marion County Prosecutor's Office, alleged at the time that Sabatini, and by the way, I'm working off a story from Fox 59. Numerous other media outlets covered this yesterday. It may be the story. I thought about leading with it today, but I know we have listeners outside of Marion County, but it's a huge story. And wherever you live, you should ears up on this.
Judge Says Broad Ripple Business Investigation Began Without Evidence of Criminal Activity
So the Marion County Prosecutor's Office alleged that Sabatini underreported his sales by nearly $4 million, and alleged underpayment then of $350,000 in state taxes between 2020 and 2023. Ryan Mears, at the time, according to Fox 59, said that this, of Sabatini, it was a pattern of corruption that hinders trust.
However, this case has been playing out in court and Tuesday, in a court filing, Judge Clark Rogers signed off. I'm reading you as it's written from Fox 59 so I don't misconstrue it. Rob didn't get it right. I don't normally just read the article from the provider, but I want to make sure I get it right as they wrote it. And again, you can read the full article over at Fox 59. Numerous other media outlets covering this as well.
In a court filing submitted Tuesday, Judge Clark Rogers signed off on a 24 page document detailing both how the prosecutor's office and the Indiana Department of Revenue were conducting a, quote, fishing expedition that was unwarranted and not based upon evidence. The court documents detail testimony from two state employees involved in the investigation. Their names are Carmen Walker and Rick Albrecht. Walker is employed as an investigator with the Marion County Prosecutor's Office. Albright is an auditor with the Indiana Department of Revenue.
Court Filing Details How Investigators Selected Businesses and Obtained Confidential Tax Records
This is a stinging indictment from this judge. A stinging indictment. Walker reportedly said that in 2023, according to Fox 59, she was instructed by Mears to, quote, look into Broad Ripple businesses. I want to repeat that back to you because that is major. Walker reportedly said that in 2023, she was instructed by Mears to, quote, look into Broad Ripple businesses and, quote, look into tax records. However, court documents say, quote, Miss Walker had no reason to suspect that any Broad Ripple business owner had committed any crime.
So it wasn't like, as Doug Carter laid out to us. Remember this earlier in the interview with Doug Carter, which if you didn't see it earlier, go back. We'll post it up. It'll be in the video section after the show. Carter lays out how they launched the investigation into Jamey Noel. He said, we suspected some stuff about Noel. We had a hunch about Noel for years, but we didn't have any tangible evidence or allegations to move forward with. He said it took the sheriff, Maples, who was the sheriff after Noel, to come to him with concrete stuff, and then he said, okay, bingo. Now we can launch an investigation. And they did.
That's not this. You have Ryan Mears telling one of his investigators, just go look into Broad Ripple businesses. According to Fox 59, Walker used Yelp to, quote, arbitrarily select 11 businesses in Broad Ripple Village. She then contacted the DOR and requested tax return information, stating it was for a criminal investigation supported by Mears.
That is unbelievable. If this is proven to be true, he should be disbarred for this and maybe worse. There was zero evidence anybody did anything wrong. They didn't have a whistleblower. They didn't have an employee. They didn't have an accountant. Nothing. They didn't have a business. She just made it up.
Walker said that, and again, I don't normally read from the story, but Fox 59 did such a wonderful job reporting on this, I wanted to give them the credit and I want to make sure I accurately report what they're reporting. Walker said that because she had no evidence of a crime and could not secure a warrant, she instead went to the Department of Revenue for tax information. So again, nobody came to them with any information, anything valid, anything concrete, anything like, oh, yeah, okay, Rock Lobster. Yeah. Here's what they're doing. She couldn't get a warrant, so she went to the Department of Revenue.
The court states despite lacking a, quote, basic understanding of business practices, Walker found no articulable evidence. Miss Walker defined a, quote, failing business as one run by a business owner who makes $85,000 or less each year because, quote, she couldn't live off that. She went with her own lifestyle and said, if the business is making less than $85,000 a year, it's failing. Her testimony confirms she lacks a basic understanding of generally recognized accounting principles, and she was in charge of investigating businesses. She should go work for Diego and check on the businesses.
Excuse my language, but what the puck? I didn't say the one you thought I said, but I wanted to. And you all know what I was saying. And then what a breakdown of our system. This is unbelievable. And again, great reporting by Fox 59.
Despite lacking evidence and an understanding of the case, court records show that Walker was able to access confidential tax records from the Department of Revenue by, quote, simply sending a one page letter vaguely referencing a criminal investigation. She supplied no evidence. She didn't lay out a case to these people. She just sent a letter and they said, okay, here's your stuff.
So if they're doing that for these people, think of who else they've done that for. If she is doing that for these people, think about who else they probably done that for and think about what other government agencies might be doing that. And the Department of Revenue is just like, sure, here's their stuff.
Which is where Albright comes in. Like Walker, court documents say that Albrecht also lacked a basic understanding of accounting and business procedures. Filing stated he was unable to define, quote, markup, quote, cost of goods sold, and gross profit margin. This is why people hate the government, and they should. This is egregious. It's disgusting.
Other examples of incompetence cited in court documents include Albrecht, again from the Department of Revenue, was unable to calculate a 100% markup of $1. This guy works for the Department of Revenue, and he can't articulate or calculate 100% markup of $1. Albrecht could not remember the names of his supervisors. Albrecht is not a licensed certified public accountant, although he sat for the test once and failed. Albright believes any business reporting less than $100,000 in yearly sales is committing tax evasion. Albrecht says the bars and restaurants should be realizing at least $100,000 per month, but only if they serve Mexican food. What the hell? And these are in court documents. This is not Fox 59 making it up. These are in the court documents, according to Fox 59.
Most importantly, Albrecht reportedly confirmed that none of the 11 businesses selected by Walker were being investigated by the Department of Revenue. They made it up. Ryan Mears, according to court documents, went to this woman, said go investigate Broad Ripple. She randomly picks 11 businesses on Yelp. She goes to the Department of Revenue, presents no evidence whatsoever because she can't get a warrant because she doesn't have any evidence they're doing anything. And this guy in the Department of Revenue is just like on a one page sheet, sure. Yeah. Here you go. What do you need?
This is unbelievable.
Judge Finds Investigation Violated Constitutional Protections Against Unreasonable Searches
The judge concluded in his ruling that the investigation by Mears' office and the Department of Revenue amounted to a baseless search and unwarranted official snooping. The factors listed in the decision include no other police agency, including IMPD, was involved in the start of the investigation. None of the targeted businesses had been referred for prosecution to Mears' office. There being, quote, absolutely no suspicion of criminal activity before the investigation, and the alleged, quote, warrantless, suspicionless, baseless search of confidential tax information.
Here's what the judge wrote. A valid criminal investigation is not created by simply typing a letter stating that a criminal investigation exists, just as yelling probable cause exists does not create probable cause. Without any doubt, the Marion County Prosecutor conducted a warrantless search that blatantly violated the Fourth Amendment. Wow.
This is unbelievable, guys. It should be the lead story on every news outlet in the entire state. In conclusion, the document states the state is asking this court to find that the Marion County Prosecutor may search the tax returns of any Marion County taxpayer without a warrant, without probable cause, without an articulable suspicion of criminal activity, and even without any suspicion of any wrongdoing, criminal or otherwise. The same is absurd and must be rejected by this court.
The Marion County Prosecutor's Office released the following response to the judge's ruling. In another Marion County court, a different judge considering a related case arising from the same investigation and involving substantially similar facts and legal arguments reached the opposite conclusion and denied the motion to suppress. We're consulting with the Indiana Attorney General's Office regarding the appropriate next steps.
Oh, I can't wait for them to get with Todd Rokita, Mears and Rokita in the same room.
Ruling Raises Broader Questions About Government Accountability and Public Trust
Look, and I will say this, as a small business owner, I don't own a bar, don't own a restaurant. I have an accountant. I do the absolute best of my ability to, and Jason will back people up on this, I am because of the OCD, as on it as you can possibly be about record keeping and everything and everything jotted down. And every year my accountant's like, you and one other guy are by far the two best. But I freely admit, as Donald Rumsfeld famously once did when he said. Donald Rumsfeld, you know, former distinguished military leader in our country, once admitted when he put in his tax return, he goes, I have no idea if this is right. I've entered the information to the best of my ability. And that is 99% of our country. Unless you're an accountant, you probably don't know. That's why you have an accountant. That's why you pay an accountant. And you know, they probably do it to the best of their ability. The tax code, to regular people, is frightening. And I will tell you, being a business owner to some extent for many people is frightening.
And the idea that every day you do the best of your ability to jot things down, to note things, to file things, to archive things. Every small business owner thinks, is this the day the government's going to show up at my door? And a lot of times the government does, and there's nothing there. But it's still a horrible experience. The audits are horrible things. They're stressful. And sometimes audits are legitimate, right? A lot of times they are. The government sees something and they say, hey, this doesn't look right. We need to look at it. And there's reasons for it.
But when you have reports like this where the government appears to be just arbitrarily targeting random people, it scares the hell out of everyone else. I mean, I'm reading that as a business owner going, oh my gosh, that could have been me. Now, again, I don't know a restaurant. I don't mean to spoil anything. I don't do near that volume of revenue. But every small business owner that reads that story, I'm telling you, it will cause them emotional harm. It will cause them psychological damage to read that, to know the government is out there not suspecting you of anything. Not that you're playing fast and loose with the rules. Not that a whistleblower came in and said so and so's not paying his taxes. None of that. The government, on a whim from the prosecutor, just started picking random businesses, and by some ridiculous standard that you were not meeting, says you need to be investigated.
And that guy was charged. His life, his reputation ruined for nothing. I feel so bad for that guy. Not just as a business owner, but as a human being, because we covered that at the time. It was a major story. I was like, oh, that sucks. I spent so many nights at Rock Lobster. That sucks. And of course, it's a news story, right? The guy's charged. You're not making it up. You're not guessing. You're like, hey, the guy got charged with these things. And then you realize it was all done because the Marion County prosecutor was pulling it out of his ass. He was making it up as he went along. There was no rhyme or reason to any of it.
That is a major story, and Ryan Mears needs to be held to account by this. And I hope when he meets with Todd Rokita, Rokita holds him to account. That should not go unnoticed. Jason says he prosecutes the prosecutor. Well, there would be a special prosecutor brought in to prosecute the prosecutor. And State Police, I would assume, would do the investigation. It would fall to the State Police. Yeah. Well, yes. Under Braun. Yes.
So anyway, that's what we know right now. I'm not being facetious. I say this like I have so many emotions about this because as somebody who's owned a business, businesses over the past 20 years, always tried to do a good job, always tried to go above and beyond wherever the line is. I try to be ten feet inside of it. But as a business owner, you're always thinking like, did I miss something? Is there something that's going to trigger the audit? My accountant hates me because he can never just, I never just drop the stuff off and, okay, thanks. I'll let you know when I'm done. He's got to spend like three hours with me asking him, did I file this right? Did I do this right? Did I do this? Yes, yes, yes. We've been at this for 20 years. You're doing it fine.
But this is the horror stories that for business owners, that you hear this stuff and you go, they're just making it up. It's not even that they didn't do something right. They're just making it up. They're just winging it and they're coming up with their own standards. And it's not the rule of law. These are the things that encourage people to not be entrepreneurs. That's the takeaway. These are the things that get people to go, nope, nope, not for me. Nope. I'll just keep working. Yeah, but you have a good idea. You can do it. Nope. Don't want to deal with it. I'll just get my paycheck. My boss will take out my taxes, and then I'll file at the end of the year.
That's really what happens here, is it keeps good people from going into business. This guy got his name through the mud. He's criminally charged. Does he get vindicated? Now think about how much money he's probably had to spend on all of this. How does he get his reputation back? What happened to his bars? Oh, yeah. You know the Rock Lobster? That's the guy that got charged with the felonies. Jason? I asked Jason when he comes in. He spent years in the bar industry. Everybody talks. Everybody knows. How does this guy get his justice now?
Great reporting by Fox 59. Many other media outlets have covered it. Let's stay on the story, guys, because it's a big deal. And if it's proven that they did weaponize the prosecutor's office and the Department of Revenue against these people. And look, I'm sure there's great people that work in the prosecutor's office. I'm sure there's great people who do great work. I hope I never have to meet any of you people, but I'm sure you're out there. Same thing with Department of Revenue. I'm sure there's fine people in the Department of Revenue who do a great job, but these two people have given those two agencies a horrible name.
And if you work in those agencies and you are one of those people that are no doubt doing the good work, you need to be all over demanding justice on this so that people have faith in their institutions. It is eroding faith in the institutions when stories like this come out, and it's keeping good people from doing great things.
Back to transcripts